The election of the winners of the Tube of the Year 2023 competition and the presentation of the winning tubes took place in Amsterdam at the end of May during the annual conference of the European Tube Manufacturers Association (etma) and the third World Tube Congress.
(Scroll through the gallery above to see the winning designs.)
A jury of seven representatives of etma member companies selected the winners in the categories of aluminium tubes, plastic tubes, laminate tubes, sustainability and prototypes. Etma says that even beyond Europe, the competition is regarded as a recognised yardstick for the performance of the industry and as an internationally valid benchmark for creativity, innovation and quality all around flexible tubes.
Aluminium tubes
This year's winner in the aluminium tube category was The POREfessional tube by Benefit Cosmetics, which belongs to the luxury group LVMH. The Californian cosmetics brand used aluminium tubes for the relaunch of its fast-smoothing pore mask. These tubes are produced by Alltub France from more than 95 per cent PCR aluminium.
The tubes have been coated with a matt, transparent lacquer that shows off the tube's brushed aluminium. A specially developed press tooling reduces the intensity of the extrusion marks along the entire length of the tube, to give a brushed effect. Another challenge lies in the printing of this tube, achieving the turquoise matt and gloss effect on the front face and obtaining the quality of print registration required at the circular matt/gloss interfaces on the tube.
Plastic tubes
In the plastic tubes category, a tube from Payot for its new Essential hair care range won the race. The tubes come from the French manufacturer Albéa and are produced in one of its competence centres for extruded plastic tubes based in Germany. At first glance, the winning tube impresses with its matt colouring and a clear, elegantly reduced design. The tubes are produced with Albéa's Thin Wall PCR Max technology.
For the closure, a matt PP Slight Cap was chosen, which is one of the lightest on the market thanks to its flat design. The shape and colour of the cap match the proportions and design of the tube, thus ensuring a harmonious appearance. This combination of Thin Wall PCR Max and the PP Slight Cap enables the brand to launch a very light tube with a high PCR material content.
Laminate tubes
The winner in the laminate tube category was the Silky Comfort Argan and Jojoba tube from Magdis Cosmetics, the largest cosmetics manufacturer on the Croatian market and a supplier of sophisticated natural cosmetics. The tubes of Biobaza Body Lotion are produced by the Slovenian manufacturer KimPai Tuba. With its convincing printed image and minimalist, understated design, the simple elegance of the tube represents the brand's commitment to sustainability, eco-friendliness and sophistication.
The tube's low profile cap and shoulder minimise plastic use by 60 per cent, adding to its eco-friendly credentials. The manufacturer's unique and lustrous MLL material not only makes the tube conspicuous and eye-catching, but it is also recognised by the Association of Plastic Recyclers (APR) as a recyclable material. All components of the tubes are made of polyethylene, making it a mono-material and recyclable product. As a final touch of finesse, compostable inks are used for the digital printing of the tube, thus enhancing the product’s overall appeal.
Sustainability
First place in the sustainability category went to an aluminium tube from the Japanese consumer goods company Kao as part of the reconfiguration of the packaging of its well-known product Goldwell Topchic Permanent Hair Color. The tubes are produced by the German manufacturer Linhardt. The aim of the joint development with Kao was to use PCR in the entire packaging to reduce the carbon footprint.
Both components of the packaging - and thus both types of material - are now produced with PCR material: the tube made of 100 per cent PCR aluminium, the closure made of 100 per cent PCR plastic. With the use of PCR aluminum slugs, the carbon footprint decreases by 92 per cent (cradle-to-gate).
The manufacturer’s PCR packaging contains 100 per cent PCR made from end-of-life aluminum scrap like cable wires or lithographic plates. This way, the resource intensive effort of collecting, sorting and cleansing needed for packaging-to-packaging recycling can be reduced. In addition, these sources of PCR are characterised by a high material availability and thus supply reliability.
The supply chain is transparent and traceable. The 100 per cent PCR plastic for the closure comes from the “yellow bag” system in Europe. A closed material cycle, which also ensures CO2 savings with its short transport routes.
Prototypes
Finally, in the prototype category, the jury chose a range of aluminium tubes from Alltub Italia as the winner. With this innovation, the tube producer responded to the increasing popularity of aluminium tubes on the market for high-end cosmetics. Attention is increasingly focusing on a design-oriented, extraordinary and distinctive appearance of the tubes.
With the introduction of its in-line over-varnishing application technique, Alltub Italia has developed an innovation that makes the aluminium tube even more attractive. With this new technology, aluminium tubes can in future be equipped and designed with a wide variety of unique and refined external coating finishes, which provide the very special look of the tube. The following effects, for example, can be realised from a range of possibilities: Soft Touch, Pearl Glaze, Iridescent Glaze or Multi-Glitter. This variety in choice of coating effects offers companies and brands attractive possibilities to add value to their products and gain new markets.
Etma secretary general Gregor Spengler said he was satisfied with the high number of participants and the outstanding quality level of this year's competition. "But what makes me particularly happy," said Spengler, "is the extremely lively participation in the prototype category. Here alone, a third of all submitted tubes went to the start. I see this as a very positive signal and a convincing indication of the continuing innovative spirit of our member companies. Our industry is obviously well positioned for the further development of the flexible tube as a packaging material of the future.”
